Menu of Olde Towne Tavern in Tuscarawas, Ohio, USA

Menu Overview

Nestled in the heart of Tuscarawas, OH, Olde Towne Tavern offers a comforting blend of classic American fare with a rustic twist. The menu shines with hearty dishes that promise a satisfying meal for anyone seeking a blend of tradition and homemade charm.

Starting with the pasta offerings, the Brick Oven Baked Pasta stands out as a robust choice. It delivers a delightful combination of rich tomato sauce, melted cheese, and perfectly al dente pasta baked to a golden crust. The Brick Oven Chicken Alfredo surprises with its creamy texture balanced by the smoky depth imparted by the brick oven, making every bite a harmonious blend of comfort and sophistication. Meanwhile, the Brick Oven Macaroni & Cheese is an indulgent treat, boasting a crisp, bubbly top layer and a luscious, cheesy interior that evokes feelings of warmth and nostalgia.

For lighter fare, the tavern’s salads deserve mention. The Crispy Chicken Salad offers a satisfying crunch against fresh greens, while the House Salad serves as the perfect palate cleanser or accompaniment to richer entrées. The Italian Salad brings a zesty mix of flavors, highlighted by sharp cheeses and savory Italian seasonings that awaken the taste buds.

To conclude a meal, the dessert selection is both inviting and comforting. The Cherry Crisp, Apple Crisp, and Blueberry Crisp each present a rustic sweetness, topped with a golden, buttery crust that pairs beautifully with a scoop of vanilla ice cream. The Brownie offers a dense, fudgy indulgence, while the Crème Brûlée impresses with its perfectly torched caramelized top and creamy custard base, showcasing refined technique alongside homestyle warmth.

Olde Towne Tavern excels in delivering dishes that honor classic flavors with a handmade touch, cooked in a brick oven that infuses every meal with subtle smokiness and depth. Whether you’re drawn by the comforting pastas, fresh salads, or the inviting dessert finishes, this tavern captures the essence of community dining and Old-World charm beautifully.